Recruiting for finance and accountancy roles comes with unique challenges. The industry demands professionals who are not only technically skilled but also detail-oriented, ethical, and able to work under pressure. Yet, many employers make critical hiring mistakes that lead to costly consequences. In this post, we highlight the most common hiring errors in finance and accountancy—and how you can avoid them.
1. Prioritising Technical Skills Over Soft Skills
Finance and accountancy professionals need a strong technical foundation, but overlooking soft skills can be a costly mistake. Communication, problem-solving, and adaptability are just as crucial, especially in roles requiring stakeholder management or leadership.
How to avoid it: Incorporate behavioural interview questions to assess communication and problem-solving abilities. Also, consider real-life case studies or situational assessments.
2. Rushing the Hiring Process
The pressure to fill a finance or accountancy vacancy quickly can lead to hiring the wrong candidate. A rushed process often results in overlooking key competencies or failing to assess cultural fit properly.
How to avoid it: Take a structured approach with clear timelines, ensuring enough time for thorough screening, interviews, and reference checks.
3. Ignoring Cultural Fit
A candidate might tick all the technical boxes but may struggle to integrate into your company culture. This can lead to disengagement, lower productivity, and higher turnover.
How to avoid it: Clearly define your company culture and values, and integrate cultural fit assessments into the hiring process. Encourage team interactions during interviews to gauge alignment.
4. Overlooking Industry-Specific Experience
Finance and accountancy professionals often work within highly regulated industries. Hiring someone without sector-specific experience can result in compliance risks and longer learning curves.
How to avoid it: Look for candidates with relevant industry exposure or ensure robust training is in place for those transitioning from different sectors.
5. Relying Too Heavily on Qualifications
While ACCA, CIMA, and ACA qualifications are essential, they don’t guarantee a candidate’s ability to perform well in a particular role. Experience, adaptability, and problem-solving skills are just as critical.
How to avoid it: Use a balanced assessment approach that includes practical tasks, case studies, and competency-based interviews.
6. Failing to Offer Competitive Packages
The finance and accountancy job market is highly competitive, and failing to offer attractive salaries, benefits, and career progression can result in losing top talent to competitors.
How to avoid it: Regularly benchmark salaries against industry standards and consider offering benefits such as flexible working, professional development, and bonuses.
7. Not Engaging Specialist Recruiters
Generalist recruitment approaches may not be effective for finance and accountancy roles. Failing to leverage specialist recruiters can lead to a poor selection of candidates.
How to avoid it: Partner with a finance recruitment agency that understands the nuances of the sector, ensuring access to high-calibre professionals.
Conclusion
Avoiding these common hiring mistakes can save your business time, money, and future headaches. By taking a structured, strategic approach to recruitment, finance and accountancy firms can secure top talent that drives success. If you need expert support in finding the right finance professionals, partnering with a specialist recruiter can make all the difference.
Need Help Hiring Finance Professionals? If you’re looking to strengthen your finance team, get in touch with our specialist recruitment experts today!
Don’t forget to follow us on LinkedIn here
